Home HockeyBuzz Register Login
Napa, CA • United States • 26 Years Old • Male
Dany Heatly has officially been traded. The summer-long soap opera of the poster-boy for millionaire crybabies is over, but was it really a good deal for all involved?

The Sharks traded two solid (not superstar, but reliable) players worth $7 million for one former superstar worth $7.5 million. I rarely agree with Ryan Garner's blogs, but he brings up a solid point in his latest one. The Sharks have roughly $21 million tied up in three players (Heatly, Joe Thornton and Patrick Marleau). They have five unrestricted free agents next year including Marleau and all-star goaltender Evgeni Nabokov. This doesn't seem like a great deal, especially when you consider that a prospect cupboard that was already bare got worse with the loss of a second-round pick.

Ordinarily I would say that the team that got the best player got the best out of a deal, but in this case Heatly has hardly made himself seem worth it. He complained about a diminished role in Ottawa, but what is he going to get in San Jose? He'll be on the top line and the powerplay because he's a natural goalscorer, but he isn't going to see penalty killing minutes.

The Sharks, meanwhile, traded two good secondary scorers who are entirely capable of logging minutes on a second or third line for any team in the NHL and doing it well. Cheechoo was often criticized for not producing after his 56-goal season in 2005-06, but he also hasn't played a full season since then and has seen his ice time drop from near 20 minutes to just over 15. Heatly's dropped from 21:44 to 20:07 before complaining about a diminished role, while Cheechoo hasn't said one word about being moved from the top line to the third and at times even the fourth line.

Michalek hasn't broken the 30-goal plateau yet, but he will. He's a strong, aggressive forechecker who makes things happen for his team and has averaged 59.3 points per season over the last three years. Imagine what he'll do for the Senators playing on a line with Daniel Alfredsson, Jason Spezza or Alexei Kovalev!

Add a second round pick to the deal for Ottawa and they get two good, young forwards and can add another talented forward or defenseman to their roster at the draft. The Sharks get a talented player, but that's it. They lose far more than they have gained.

As for the longterm fallout, that's still to be determined. however I agree with Eklund's blog on the front page. I've been saying all summer that a player with a no trade clause should not have the right to reject trades after he demands to be traded. He should at least be required to submit a list of teams to which he will go without complaint. Dany Heatly did not do that. He demanded a trade and when he got his wish to be traded he refused to go. He forced Ottawa into a hole. Bryan Murray had no negotiating power. All he could do was say to the other GMs, "here he is boys, come get him." Personally I hope that Heatly gets a nice wakeup call from his former teammates on Dec. 1 when the Senators come to the Shark tank for all the trouble he caused them.
Filed Under:   Heatly   Sharks   Senators   Cheechoo  
September 13, 2009 10:11 AM ET | Delete
Decent read. I agree that although the Sharks will be decent this year(still need 2 more players to fill their roster with only 600,000), they are in trouble in the long run. Top 3 forwards worth 22 million colleticly and then boyle and nabokov costing another 11 million. If the salary cap goes down to 50-52million next year the Sharks will have under about 18million for 18 positions. Ouch. Even if the cap stays the same it's only 22million for 18 players.
September 13, 2009 3:44 PM ET | Delete
I feel for the sharks in this one. not because I'm an ottawa fan, but because Heatley is plain and simple more trouble than he's worth. I love Cheech and I've only ever seen Michalek play on the highlights, which can only be good news for us sens fans. I'll wipe my butt with the 50 goals he scores, even if this trade turns out badly for the sens, it's better than having heatley here.
September 13, 2009 5:34 PM ET | Delete
Heatly and Thorton sould work fantastically together. Since the lock out no player has more assists than Thorton and only two have more goals than Heatly seems like a match made in heaven to me. However after the top 6 the sharks are not very good and it is because of this that they wil not be as successful this season. Ottawa did not get much in return for Heatly considering what Edmonton offered.
September 13, 2009 7:40 PM ET | Delete
Who cares if Heatley doesn't kill penalties. And San Jose won't miss Cheechoo because Setoguchi is younger, cheaper, and better. Also, the cap won't go down. Next year's cap is based on this year's league revenue and the worst part of the recession has past.
Notice to Internet Explorer Users
There is an issue with the form blow that will make it appear that nothing happens when you click the post message button below. To see your message, after you click the post message button, refresh this page. Sorry for the troubles, we hope to have it fixed soon.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to leave a comment.

Blog Archive