Home HockeyBuzz Register Login
The Rock, NJ • United States • 35 Years Old • Male
Source Vancover Sun:

VANCOUVER — The National Hockey League is clearly trying to draw a line in the sand, but may not have a legal leg to stand on in its rejection of Ilya Kovalchuk's 17-year, $102-million US contract with the New Jersey Devils, one prominent agent said Wednesday.

J.P. Barry of CAA Sports, whose large roster of clients includes Vancouver Canucks forwards Daniel and Henrik Sedin and Mason Raymond, said he doesn't see how the league can win what appears to be an almost certain showdown with the NHL Players' Association over its rejection of the deal.

"I have already done quite a few contracts that were front-end loaded and there is no language in the CBA addressing the term of contracts," Barry said. "So I am not sure what grounds they intend to rely upon."

Barry has negotiated front-loaded contracts in recent years for the likes of Dany Heatley, Daniel Alfredsson and Mattias Ohlund, but none of those deals flatline in the final years quite the way Kovalchuk's does.

The Russian sniper is scheduled to receive just $550,000 a season in the last five years of the deal, which expires in 2027 when Kovalchuk will be 44. Conversely, Kovalchuk is to receive $11.5 million a year for five years beginning in 2012-13.

"Obviously, there is no contract that has ever had the maximum and the minimum in the same deal and there is no contract that has had five minimum salaries going out the back end and there is no contract that takes a player past age 42," Barry said.

Other than saying it is examining its options, the NHLPA has not yet responded to the NHL's decision on the Kovalchuk deal. But it's almost certain to launch a grievance unless the Devils and Kovalchuk restructure the deal. If a grievance is filed, an independent arbitrator would be appointed to rule on the contract and that ruling would be binding.

Barry doesn't think the NHL could win its case.

"To me the only grounds they can possibly use is that he is not going to play those years and this is somehow a cap circumvention," he said. "That would be their only argument because there is no limit on term in the CBA."

The NHL clearly does think the Devils are attempting to circumvent the salary cap, but New Jersey certainly isn't the first NHL team to go down that road.

The league announced its decision on its website late Tuesday, just a few hours after Kovalchuk appeared at a Newark, N.J. news conference to officially announce his signing.

Deputy commissioner Bill Daly issued the following statement on Wednesday morning: "The contract has been rejected by the League as a circumvention of the Collective Bargaining Agreement. Under the CBA, the contract rejection triggers a number of possible next steps that may be elected by any or each of the NHLPA, the Player and/or the Club. In the interim, the player is not entitled to play under the contract, nor is he entitled to any of the rights and benefits that are provided for thereunder. The League will have no further comment on this matter pending further developments."

The league had previously served notice it wasn't comfortable with the recent rash of front-loaded contracts and investigated, but later approved, contracts for Vancouver's Roberto Luongo, Chicago's Marian Hossa and Philadelphia's Chris Pronger.

Luongo signed a 12-year, $64-million contract extension with the Canucks last season. That deal will pay Luongo $10 million in 2010-11, about $6.7 million from 2012-13 through 2017-18, about $3.3 million in 2018-19 and about $1.6 million in 2019-20 before declining to $1 million for the final two seasons. Luongo will be 42 when the deal expires.

The Canucks are believed to have made the argument to the league that goaltenders traditionally have longer shelf lives than other positions. Dominik Hasek and Dwayne Roloson are the most recent goalies to play into their 40s.

Gilles Lupien, the agent who negotiated Luongo's deal, did not want to wade into the controversy surrounding the Kovalchuk contract.

"I don't want to comment on another agent's work," said Lupien, who suggested that if the NHL is unhappy with these kinds of contracts then it should negotiate changes to the collective bargaining agreement.

The Devils, who employ the former head of the NHL contract registry, Stephen Pellegrini, said they knew they were pushing the boundaries of what is allowed when they announced the deal.

"There is nothing we have done wrong. This is within the rules," Devils general manager Lou Lamoriello said Tuesday. "This is the CBA. There are precedents that have been set, but I would agree that we shouldn't have these (type of contracts).

"But I'm also saying that, because it's legal and this is something ownership felt like doing for the right reasons, then it was done."

• Barry said he has had no discussions this week with Canucks assistant general manager Laurence Gilman regarding restricted free agent Mason Raymond, whose arbitration hearing is set for Monday in Toronto.

"We're preparing for arbitration on Monday and we'll see what happens," Barry said. "Sometimes after you exchange your briefs there's a discussion about settlement. The brief exchange would not be until Saturday morning."

Gilman also said he does not anticipate a settlement before Monday's hearing.

"As it stands today, we are preparing for arbitration," Gilman said.

Raymond's salary cap hit last season was $833,333, including bonuses. He's believed to be seeking between $2.5 and $3 million.

A decision on winger Jannik Hansen's arbitration case, which was heard Tuesday, is expected Thursday.

Read more: http://www.vancouversun.c.../story.html#ixzz0uN9CBQNI
Filed Under:   Kovalchuck   Nerw Jersey Devils  
July 21, 2010 10:21 PM ET | Delete
July 21, 2010 11:20 PM ET | Delete
They may not win, but a line has been drawn so this doesn't explode the next time the CBA is reviewed. This contract may be the latest in a long line of long front loaded contracts, but is the only one where the player is clearly not going to be within the normal expectations of a player specializing in a certain position.
July 21, 2010 11:23 PM ET | Delete
The NHL is a complete joke right now, Bettman and Daly have no case they are just looking to save face with all of this. This is there fault this is what they put in the CBA and there is nothing they can do, whether it goes to Arbitration or not Bettman and the NHL will look like complete asses by the end of all this.
July 22, 2010 12:03 AM ET | Delete
The league will win if Kovy decides not to wait weeks for the ruling and sign another contract either with the Devils or somewhere else. If he waits for the ruling and the arbitrator rules in favor of the league, Kovy's options will be few.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to leave a comment.

Blog Archive

10 On Kovi free agency
12 WOW The Devils Make A Great Move!!!!
12 John MacLean is hands on as Devils open prospects camp
12 Is Ilya Kovalchuk moving closer to signing with Los Angeles?
13 Has Kovalchuck lost his footing with New Jersey Devils Fans?
13 Elias understands Kovalchuk's dilemma
14 Elias excited for what future holds
15 Lots of talk but nothing to announce yet on Kovalchuk
15 Kovalchuk Looking Less and Less Likely for New Jersey Devils
15 Kovalchuk desperately wants to be the highest paid Russian!!
15 Devils don't offer veteran center Eric Chouinard a contract
15 Anton Volchenkov: Devils were my second choice
15 MacLean meets the A-Train
16 Are Ilya Kovalchuk's salary demands tied to Alex Ovechkin?
16 Newly-signed Tyler Eckford wants to play his way into a job
16 Devils' World Won't End if Kovy Bypasses Newark
18 Kings believed they had a 50-50 chance of signing Kovinuts
19 Brian Rolston knows that changes are coming for Devils
19 Devils' signing of Ilya Kovalchuk puts a smile on John Mac!!
19 Dainius Zubrus: signing Ilya Kovalchuk was to shake up the Devils
19 What might happen next?????
20 Who Will Go???
20 Which Contracts Will Lou Dump Now?
20 Left winger Ilya Kovalchuk, there is significance to #17
21 Once Kovalchuk's deal is settled, attention to Zach!!!
21 NHL doesn't believe Ilya Kovalchuk will stay untill Age 44
21 contracts similar to Ilya Kovalchuk's deal with Devils
21 NHL Players' Assocation issues statement On Kovi
21 Lamoriello statement on Kovalchuk signing
21 ’t win Ilya Kovalchuk contract showdown
22 It's in hands of Ilya Kovalchuk and union
22 NHL might have picked wrong fight
22 LA Kings Dean Lombardi backs up Kovalchuck Contract
24 NHLPA to file grievance
25 The Kovi Saga
25 NHL prosecution merely a temper tantrum
26 Devils wait for players' union to file grievance
26 contract could trigger a war between Devils and NHL
27 Decision on Kovalchuk is expected nexty week
28 Kovalchuk contract could be restructured by arbitrator
28 Yann Danis Going to KHL
28 Mark Fraser Signed....
29 Newly-signed Mark Fraser vows to be 'mean, physical Player
30 Arbitrator has been agreed upon
30 Kovalchuck Hearing?????
31 Arbitrator - Richard Bloch a NEw Jersey Native
31 Association agree on arbitrator to rule on Ilya Kovalchuk
03 Kovalchuk will attend contract hearing
03 Devils will wear retro jerseys March 18 vs. Washington
04 D day for Kovi and the Devils
05 Roller Hockey at the Jersey Shore
06 Jim Dowd Shore High School Hockey Game set for Sunday
06 Is this is a set-up between Lou and Gary???
09 The arbitration decision coming today
11 Translated article from soviet sports kovalchuck
11 Devils name Rick Kowalsky head coach at Albany
12 HEATS ON!!!!
12 Where do the Devils stand in the market???
16 Today might be the day
16 90 million over 10-13 for kovi?
16 Russian News Paper Reports Devs and Kovi....
17 Contract submitted???
18 Another Quiet day in the Kovi Front
19 Devils still waiting to see what happens with Kovy
19 “Status Quo” On Ilya Kovalchuk And Devils
20 Devils After Marc-Andre Bergeron???
20 Kovi wants nothing to do with the KHL
20 Elias on the Move???
21 Questions Surround Devils in Wake of Kovalchuck saga
22 Brian Burke Testified Against Ilya Kovalchuk Contract???
22 Devils Bringing Hockey Back To Atlantic City
23 Patrik Elias could be moved to sign fellow winger Zach Paris
23 Today could be the Day!!!
23 News 1130 out of Vancouver Reports on Kovi
23 Possible contract for Kovalchuck
23 Devils add more youth to the roster
23 EJHradek_ESPN Reports NJ Devils meet with the NHL
24 News 12 New Jersey Reports on Kovi Contract...
24 Bryce Salvador to Stars...
25 NHL 2 Devils 0.....
25 Lamoriello not frustrated by Kovalchuk process
25 Commish denies report of deal rejection
26 – NYPOST.com
26 Looks Like KHL is out of the question
27 Could this be finalyy over???
30 Devils could part with Zajac if Kovalchuk stays
30 ’ contract, but Kovalchuk retires
31 ’s official decision on Kovalchuk’s TODAY!!!!!
31 Niemi a Devil?????