Home HockeyBuzz Register Login
"Off The Post: Inching Closer to the Future"
Long Island, NY • United States • 25 Years Old • Male
If you ask me, right behind our timid, inconsistent offense that has had great difficulty burying the puck this season, this team has been lacking something else from last year that was notable throughout the season. It's not just Jason Blake's 40 goals or the fearless leader in Alexei Yashin....JUST KIDDING! No, it's not baseball swings with hockey sticks or number 3 exploding his "Poti Power" on the blue line..

It's team toughness. This team used to stick up for each others linemates whenever it was called upon. It was an element that Ted Nolan promised would be put back in the game, and you could feel it in his words when he announced he was going to "bring back hitting to the ballroom dancing," during his first press conference as an Islander.



There have been just a few moments that we've seen it this year. I do remember one or two times early this season where Guerin was quick to deliver a face-wash and shove for a hit from behind on Tank or Comrie, or Hunter dropping the gloves for his first NHL fight...but it didn't take long for that element to die down. Simon, who was supposed to be our enforcer, rarely dropped the gloves or even as much threw a body check. But we can thank him for the tap-dancing lessons he displayed on Ruutu's ankle.

We're missing guys like Arron Asham, who although didn't fight on a consistent basis, did it more often than anyone. Of all people, Comrie - who's supposed to be our first line center - has taken on the liberties of dropping his gloves and visor to generate momentum when it seems like there is nothing else to do to motivate this team.

Last night can be seen as a prime example. Our top rookie this year, Blake Comeau, was elbowed, shoved to the ice, speared where the sun doesn't shine, and then sucker punched even though he didn't drop his gloves. And to add to it, Comeau is only 28 games old and was getting attacked by Garnet Exelby, whose been in this league for 5 years. And whose the first player to defend him? Bryan Berard, a guy who has a terrible history of injuries and ailments that has been unable to stay in the lineup due to inconsistent play..and he's the first one to risk his playing time by defending the youngster, Comeau. I can distinctly remember back in the day when Raffi Torres was still wearing the blue, orange, and white, and he received a late-from behind hit, causing Eric Cairns to immediately drop the gloves to defend our young forward. Where has that attitude gone?



By all means, props to Berard..because that was the first sign of team toughness that I've seen since the beginning of the season. Just the other night against Phili, Comrie was checked from behind face first into the boards, and NO ONE did anything about it. Not even our leader, Bill Guerin. Granted, we did get a powerplay out of it and there are times where emotions need to be contained. But that's the problem..for the vast majority of the season it seems like this team has lacked the emotion that it had last year. It's gotten to the point where guys like Mike Comrie and Bryan Berard have taken the liberty upon themselves to defend our players instead of the likes of Guerin, Sutton or Witt.



Don't get me wrong, I am huge fans of the guys I just criticized, but it would be appreciated and well-served if that "Grit. Character. Heart" banner on the Islanders web-site was displayed on a more consistent basis. We saw it last year and we know Ted Nolan has the ability to reach out to his players. So then why does it seem like it's missing now?

I don't believe in the excuse that the "New NHL" has removed fighting from the game. Let's just take a look at the Anaheim Ducks and their mighty 54 fighting majors. 54! I believe the Islanders may be somewhere around 10 or so, give or take a few. There are still tough players in this league more than willing to drop the gloves, and they're not all on the Ducks. Ian Laperriere of the Avelanche is just one example. He has 13 fighting majors alone this season, and only 9 minor penalties. Tough and disciplined - what this team needs.

So why doesn't this team have it? Well, we may be looking at the wrong group. We knew we had the "castaways" that no one wanted in free agent lingo. As fans we tried to stay positive but it has become clear that staying positive has its downfalls, and at times facts need to be taken as facts, and changes are necessary, without question.

I'm sure there are more "Ted Nolan-type" players out there, it's just a matter of finding them.
Filed Under:   Islanders   Guerin   Comeau   Comrie   NHL  
February 17, 2008 9:23 PM ET | Delete
I really think the NHL has removed the team concept model with their instigator bs penalty. I mean Berard was kicked out for jumping on a guy that attacked an unwilling opponent. Also, look who was on the ice at that moment Comeau (who plays a tough game) Neilson and Tamellini. Plus Berard and MAB. Who exactly is coming to help in that situation. But I do agree the Isles could use more grit, and the youth are are drafting seem to have that element when you look at Comeau, Bergenheim, and Okposo. The instigator rule has to go, so that players are able to protect their teammates again.
February 17, 2008 10:17 PM ET | Delete
Well I think Berard was thrown out because his jersey came off. I'm not 100 % on this but I've heard Jaffe and others say that if your jersey isn't tied down and comes off during a fight, it's an automatic game misconduct. You do make a point though about who was on the ice at the time, but it still, like you said, is something the team is missing as a whole.
February 18, 2008 8:00 AM ET | Delete
I think you're looking in the wrong place for the Islander's grit, character and heart. The team is only beginning to find the pieces of the puzzle that somehow got lost under the couch for 20 or so games. Looking back at the beginning of the season and last three games is where you'll be able to see the semblance of a picture coming together. With the absence of true 'enforcers' like Simon (hence the quotation marks), Sim, and to a lesser extent Witt, who were supposed to give us that physical spark, the rest of the club displayed their grit the only way they can. It's difficult to ignore the surging offense as a result of hard work, getting to the front of the net and the Islanders staying on their feet despite pressure from big defensemen. For these reasons you're seeing a more disciplined club. Look back at the rough times they've had, and look at the list of injuries. When the Islanders can't control themselves and take penalties, they lose. With the absence of key defensemen, that risk is tenfold. They can't be taking risks like that right now, whether they're trying to build player value for trades, or taking a shot at the playoffs. With their recent play, they know they can't afford it. If it means letting someone get jostled around, well, you can look at it as taking one for the team. Andy Sutton has been blocking shots like an animal. Would you rather him getting his huge frame in front of a slapshot? Or warming the bench in the Sin Bin because he couldn't control himself, or because someone got pushed around? In this case, I think team discipline and decisive wins are going to promote team unity a hell of a lot more than taking penalties because a fellow hockey player needs protection.
February 18, 2008 1:44 PM ET | Delete
It's not just about fighting or always responding with a fight when someone gets knocked down. The fact is that we can barely say we've done that. We can't even say that we've made that mistake at a crucial point of a game. Andy Sutton has been blocking shots and it's great that he's doing so. But at times when we're losing and having trouble generating momentum, the team would be well-served if someone fought someone in order to provide a spark. It doesn't even have to be a fight necessarily. Sutton hasn't thrown a huge hit that I can remember since the last time we played the Lightning in Tampa and he threw a thunderous hip check. The team needs more of that. I don't mean to sound like I'm picking on Sutton because I think he's one of our top defenceman, and an excellent signing. What I've said can be said about any player who was brought here for that element of the game. We need more grit, or for the grit to actually be displayed, if we're going to advertise it as who we are. It will just make us that much better of a team.
February 18, 2008 2:19 PM ET | Delete
As far as I'm concerned, if they can keep scoring goals like they have the past 3 games I'm not going to complain about not playing a huge physical game. Grit doesn't just come from being able to hammer the other team into submission, it's a show of determination to win and score through hard work and a grinding effort, which is what they've shown in their recent play.
Notice to Internet Explorer Users
There is an issue with the form blow that will make it appear that nothing happens when you click the post message button below. To see your message, after you click the post message button, refresh this page. Sorry for the troubles, we hope to have it fixed soon.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to leave a comment.

Blog Archive